Top 100 Guided by Voices Songs Part 1
Alright, here it goes. Counting backwards from 100!
100)
“Now I’m Crying” - Wish in One Hand…
This song is a song I know relatively little about in terms of the whole Guided by Voices oeuvre. What I know, I know from listening to the song. It holds some of the desperation of earlier GbV classics, while having that lovely sound that would take over in the wake of the disintegration of the “classic” line up of the band. This one’s probably not a good starting point in terms of diving into this band, but it is a good song by a good band.
99)
“Dust Devil” - King Shit and the Golden Boys
This is another one that doesn’t quite fit the GbV oeuvre, but is nonetheless a great track. In it, you can hear the sense of vocal harmony that is ultimately the band’s calling card. However, in this track (as it will be in most early Guided by Voices tracks) the overall structure of the song puts it more in the realm of American post-punk acts like REM than the british invasion that would prove to be Pollard and co.’s main influence as they grew as a band.
Also, allow me to note now, King Shit and the Golden Boys is a compilation of early recordings that was released in 1995. These tracks are basically impossible to find elsewhere.
98)
“Perhaps Now the Vultures” - Vampire on Titus
Here we have another track that captures a band that I don’t think has quite found its voice yet. I may be tricked by the sound of the guitar on this one, because the “lead” guitar track is quite spacey and, if I may, “post-punky.” Regardless, this is a better introduction into the spirit of Guided by Voices than either of its predecessors on this list. Robert Pollard sounds like Robert Pollard on this track, and his lyrics evoke the desperation that make the earlier “classic” GbV records hit so close to home for myself and many of my friends.
97)
“2nd Moves to Twin” - King Shit and the Golden Boys
Robert “Uncle Bob” Pollard attributed a lot of his success to sticking to the 4 p’s of songwriting (pop, punk, psychedelic, and progressive). This is one of the prime examples of utilizing the third P. The guitar work on this track is not particularly complex, but its impact is. Add to that the somewhat cryptic nature of the song’s lyrics and you have a (relatively) modern lo-fi psychedelic classic on your hands.
96)
“Red Gas Circle” - Propeller
This marks my first entry from what are agreed to be the classic albums (though Vampire on Titus belongs in that category, despite what some AV Club jerks may say.) This track is a rather sedate Pollard tune, and generally (at least when it comes to GbV classic) that is the realm of Tobin Sprout. But anyway, I think the simple instrumentation of this song allows what is the greatest strength of Guided by Voices (vocal harmonies) to shine through.
95)
“The Hard Way” - Same Place the Fly Got Smashed
The guitar shimmers, the drums pound, and Pollard sings his heart out on this one. This is among the earliest heartfelt punk-influenced tracks in the band’s discography. Its optimistic tone (musically speaking at least) fits with a lot of the band’s work, though in the context of this record (a concept album about alcoholism) it is a bit of a false positive.
94)
“Hold on Hope” - Do the Collapse
So, Guided by Voices signed to a major label at some point. I ain’t gonna apologize for that. I also ain’t gonna apologize for the fact that this song was on Scrubs (a show I hate.) This song is a terrific song. I would not recommend it for first time GbV listeners, but it’s a good song that may attract otherwise uninterested listeners to the band.
93)
“Discussing Wallace Chambers” - Devil Between my Toes
This is the second track on the first Guided by Voices LP. It doesn’t fit the rest of the band’s discography at all, really. The guitar work stands out as its own thing far more than would happen later. Not that that’s necessarily a bad thing, the guitar work on this track is very interesting. Also, the bridge of this song is beautiful. It sounds like REM, but it sounds like a better version of REM.
92)
“Squirmish Frontal Room” - King Shit and the Golden Boys
This one is on here mostly for the lyrics. The lyrics to this song rip so hard. Also the chorus of “No no no no no no” is the best chorus of one repeated word ever recorded.
91)
“Blue Babbleships Bay” - Class Clown Spots a UFO
I’m not going to front with you, person reading my blog, I have not spent a whole hell of a lot of time with the two Guided by Voices records that have come out so far this year. They probably need more time to sink in. HOWEVER, this song immediately hit me. It captures a lot of the early 90s spirit of this band. Robert Pollard has, in interviews, expressed fondness for the verbal nonsense often written in song by John Lennon, and few GbV songs invoke that spirit as well as this one.
90)
“Old Battery” - Devil Between my Toes
First track on the first LP. Again, this record is the best REM record ever recorded. The chorus of “Die hard” makes me happy for a completely unexplainable reason. Bob never sounds like this again.
89)
“A Salty Salute” - Alien Lanes
This is the album opener for Alien Lanes. This track definitely captures a band that is about to become a live powerhouse. There isn’t a whole hell of a lot to discuss about this track. Its chorus of “The Club is Open” has become a quite apropos anthem for the band.
88)
“Alright” - Alien Lanes
Speaking of apropos, this is the closer of Aline Lanes! Its lyrics consist of one word (wanna guess? The answer’s in the title.) The guitar (which is uncharacteristically high in the mix here) really lifts the listener with its ascending, major solo into a soothing, harmonic chorus of voices singing “alright.”
87)
“Glad Girls” - Isolation Drills
This is a stupid pop song on a stupid pop album (at least in comparison to the rest of the band’s collection.) HOWEVER, while I was living at home with my parents after college, their favorite radio station played this song during dinner, and we had a bit of a moment, and that moment was nice, and nice moments are why we listen to music.
86)
“Liquid Indian” - Do the Collapse
Here is another song that rests heavily on Robert Pollard’s vocal harmony laurels. This song is probably underwhelming otherwise, but the “Aahooooooh” underneath the chorus totally nails me every damn time!
85)
“King and Caroline” - Alien Lanes
I think the main reason I like this song is that I always pictured it as being kind of sarcastic, and that the “king” is kind of a dildo, and I knew a dude who dated a girl named Caroline, and he was kind of a dildo, so the ideas fused in my brain and gave me a deep and everlasting connection to this song.
84)
“Underwater Explosions” - Under the Bushes Under the Stars
Oh boy! Our first UTBUTS entry! This record is, in my opinion, vastly underrated. This, my lowest ranked song on said album, represents, to my estimation, the very average of this record’s songs. Or perhaps not average, but median. Anyway this song is a good Guided by Voices song (the first to appear on this list that I would recommend listening to if you’ve never heard of the band, though not the best jumping off point) and it is on a very good album.
83)
“A Good Flying Bird” - Alien Lanes
So far this list has been dominated by Robert Pollard songs. This ditty is by his songwriting foil, Mr. Tobin Sprout. Toby’s songs on Alien Lanes and Under the Bushes Under the Stars remind me of mentos commercials for some reason. This is the one that best captures that mentos thing.
82)
“The Goldheart Mountaintop Queen Directory” - Bee Thousand
OH SHIT! BEE THOUSAND! Go out and buy Bee Thousand now, I’ll wait.
…
Oh good, you’re back! This track is a great example of what works about Bee Thousand (and makes it among the best… maybe 10 albums of all of Rock and Roll). It doesn’t sound like anything else on the record, but fits RIGHT in. Also, it’s about tripping on acid and seeing your son’s face.
81)
“Sheetkickers” - Under the Bushes Under the Stars
Robert Pollard, like John Lennon before him, had some less than savory relationships with the women in his life. All men who have relationships with women have bad ones! But here we see some truly brutal honesty about those relationships. For example, “I would like to kill you, but that would suit you fine I realize.” It’s a bad thing to think, but we think it when going through bad break ups. Be honest. Also, the melody on this song is sweet, much like John Lennon’s songs about killing ladies!
80)
“14 Cheerleader Coldfront” - Propeller
This is another Tobin Sprout song. Its importance to the GbV discography can never be understated, however. On its surface, it is a sweet song, melodic, soft, pleasant. But there is a strange darkness that hovers over it. Haunting the listener like a creeping boy in an alley.
79)
“Auditorium” - Alien Lanes
Perhaps the greatest strength of Alien Lanes lies in the inclusion of many short songs. This is one of the album’s strongest. The interplay between the lead guitar, Pollard’s primary vocal track, and Pollard’s secondary vocal track make this just over a minute track a pool well worth swimming in multiple times.
78)
“Wished I was a Giant” - Vampire on Titus
Primarily, what I love about this track is that it sounds like Robert Pollard was shouting the lyrics into a microphone that was an entire hallway away from him. Also, the guitar part and Pollard’s jubilant shouting in the “chorus” are incredibly uplifting.
77)
“Some Drilling Implied” - Propeller
I like to imagine that the lyrics of this song are an actual speech an actual coach gave to Robert Pollard at some point. (Brief sojourn, Robert Pollard was the first pitcher in the history of Wright State University to pitch a no-hitter!) Anyway, I’ve seen the band close live sets with it before, and it works beautifully!
76)
“Sister I Need Wine” - Isolation Drills
The stark guitar chords play with the strings and Robert Pollard’s vocals to create a dark mood that I imagine allows Bob to explore his relationship with drink. Also, “sister I need wine,” is a really great thing to say when you need a boozenin’ real bad.
PART ONE FINISHED!